The Best Tivly Alternatives for Commercial Insurance Agencies
Tivly sells real-time inbound-intent commercial insurance leads, business owners who filled out a quote request and, per Tivly's own model, are actively shopping right now, drawn from a claimed pool of 1 million-plus annual SMB quote requests. Tivly's own site claims up to 3.5x ROI in top campaigns, an 80% "success rate" in a case study, and 1,800-plus producers served, figures that are vendor self-reported and not independently verified in this research. Pricing is quote-only. Agencies who want a documented inbound-lead pool can request pricing from Tivly directly, or use VA Horizon exclusive, double-confirmed meetings for a $300 one-time setup plus a published $300 to $550 per meeting, disclosed here as our own service, not a neutral rating.
Pay per booked meeting. No retainer.
VA Horizon vs Tivly
| Decision Point | VA Horizon | Tivly |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | A booked, double-confirmed meeting with a qualified business owner, on your calendar. | A real-time inbound lead: a business owner who filled out a commercial insurance quote request and, per Tivly's model, is actively shopping right now. (source) |
| Sourcing direction | Outbound. Human + AI SDRs text prospects based on your criteria and x-date instead of waiting for one to raise a hand. | Inbound. Tivly claims 1 million-plus annual SMB quote requests feed its lead pool. (source) |
| Pricing | $300 one-time setup, then a published $300 to $550 per booked meeting, in full on this page. | Not public. Tivly's pricing is quote-only. (source) |
| Performance claims | A published 60% baseline show rate, backed by a 24-hour, 2-hour, and 15-minute confirmation sequence. | Up to 3.5x ROI, an 80% "success rate," and 1,800-plus producers served, all Tivly's own self-reported figures. This research did not find independent verification of any of them. (source) |
| What still has to happen after the lead arrives | Nothing. The meeting is already scheduled and double-confirmed when it lands on your calendar. | You still have to call and convert the inbound lead yourself, the same underlying limitation Quality Contact Solutions describes for any prospecting a producer works solo. (source) |
| Proof behind the charge | An SMS transcript plus a 24-hour, 2-hour, and 15-minute confirmation log ships with every billed meeting. | Tivly's ROI and success-rate figures are presented as claims on its own site; this research did not find independent verification of them. |
What Tivly claims about itself, examined.
What Tivly actually claims, labeled honestly
Tivly's own site claims up to 3.5x ROI in top campaigns and an 80% "success rate" in a case study, and states it serves 1,800-plus producers off a pool of 1 million-plus annual SMB quote requests. Every one of those numbers is Tivly's own self-reported figure. This research did not find independent verification of any of them, so treat them as vendor claims, not audited results.
Inbound intent's real advantage, credited fairly
A business owner who filled out a quote request is, by definition, further along than a cold x-date prospect who has not raised a hand yet. That is a genuine structural advantage inbound intent has, not a claim worth disputing on its own terms.
What outbound buys that inbound cannot promise
Inbound volume depends on how many businesses happen to search and fill out a form this month, drawing from the same finite pool Tivly cites. Outbound gives you control over volume and targeting instead: you choose the criteria and the x-date window, rather than waiting on demand you do not control.
VA Horizon, disclosed position
This is our own appointment-setting service, not a neutral ranking. VA Horizon sells exclusive, double-confirmed commercial insurance meetings for a $300 one-time setup plus a published $300 to $550 per booked meeting, with the SMS transcript and confirmation log behind every charge.
Who should consider Tivly versus VA Horizon.
Consider Tivly when
You want a shot at businesses actively shopping right now and are comfortable with quote-only pricing and vendor-reported performance claims that were not independently verified in this research.
Look at an alternative, including VA Horizon, when
You want control over volume and targeting instead of depending on how many businesses fill out a form this month, and a published rate instead of a quote-only conversation.
Tivly alternatives, answered.
What does Tivly sell?
Are Tivly's ROI and success-rate numbers verified?
How much does Tivly cost?
What happens after I get a Tivly lead?
Is VA Horizon a direct Tivly alternative?
Get a published rate, not a quote-only conversation.
Book a 15-minute call. We confirm your qualification criteria, lock your rate inside the published $300 to $550 range, and start texting your x-date list within days.
Recommended next steps