Skip to main content
VA Horizon
Book a Call
Why VA Horizon

Why the Producer Shortage Makes “Just Hire Someone” a Worse Answer in Insurance Than in Any Other B2B Vertical We Serve

Quick answer

Six B2B verticals, and only one of them requires a state-issued license before a new hire can legally solicit business. Commercial insurance is that one. SaaS, MCA, merchant services, staffing, and marketing-agency sales roles all let a strong new hire start selling as soon as they are trained. Insurance adds a licensing and carrier-appointment process on top of that, layered onto an industry already facing an estimated 400,000-worker retirement deficit and a workforce skewed toward 1.37 million workers aged 55 or older against just 214,000 aged 20 to 24.

Even once a new producer is fully licensed, replacing one who leaves costs 75% to 150% of their salary, $15,000 to $50,000 in direct cost alone, against a sales cycle that can take over two years to convert a first prospect into a client. Stacked together, those facts are why “just hire someone” is a structurally weaker answer in this vertical than in any of the other five VA Horizon serves.

One Vertical Out of Six Has a Legal Gate Between Hiring and Selling

VA Horizon serves six B2B verticals, SaaS, MCA, merchant services, staffing, marketing agencies, and commercial insurance, and “just hire someone” means something different in each of them. In five of the six, a strong new hire can be trained and put on the phone within weeks, limited only by how fast they actually get good at the job. Commercial insurance is the exception: a new hire cannot legally solicit business at all until they clear a state licensing process, a legal gate none of the other five verticals impose.

What the License Requires, and How Big the System Behind It Is

Transacting insurance, including soliciting and advising on coverage, is a licensed act under state law. California Insurance Code Section 31 defines an insurance agent as a person specifically authorized to transact insurance, on behalf of an insurer, not a general permission anyone hired into the role automatically holds. That licensing requirement sits on top of a large, actively administered national system: the National Insurance Producer Registry processed approximately 185.9 million credentialing and reporting transactions in 2025 alone, a 29% year-over-year increase, and collected roughly $1.38 billion in state licensing and regulatory fees. Neither figure describes a rubber-stamp process.

Want this handled for you?

Pay per booked meeting for your industry. No retainer.

Book a B2B Call

The Demographic Hole “Just Hire Someone” Is Supposed to Fill

The talent pool this licensing gate sits in front of is already thin and aging. The industry faces an estimated 400,000-worker deficit as boomer-generation agents retire, against a workforce skewed sharply older, 1.37 million workers aged 55 or older versus just 214,000 aged 20 to 24. That is not a temporary hiring-market blip; it is a structural pipeline problem a licensing requirement makes slower to solve, not faster.

The Cost of Getting It Wrong, Even After the License Clears

Licensing is the entry cost, not the whole cost. Replacing a producer who leaves, licensed or not, runs 75% to 150% of their departing salary, $15,000 to $50,000 in direct replacement cost alone, and three mid-level exits in a single year can cost an agency $146,000 to $292,000 combined. That expense sits against a sales cycle that can take over two years to convert a brand-new commercial insurance prospect into an actual client, meaning a licensed new hire who does not work out is an expensive mistake discovered slowly, not quickly.

Why the Other Five Verticals Do Not Share This Structural Problem

None of VA Horizon’s other five B2B verticals impose anything comparable. A new SaaS sales hire, a new MCA ISO rep, a new merchant services rep, a new staffing recruiter, a new marketing-agency account executive, all of them can be trained and selling inside weeks, with no state-issued credential standing between hiring and legally doing the job. Insurance is the only one of the six where “we hired someone strong” and “that person can legally start selling” are not the same milestone.

What “Just Hire Someone” Has to Mean in This Vertical

None of this argues against hiring. It argues for budgeting the licensing and appointment timeline as its own real cost, not an afterthought that happens automatically once someone accepts an offer. An agency that plans a hiring timeline the same way it would for one of VA Horizon’s other five verticals is planning against a milestone that, in insurance specifically, does not yet exist on day one.

What Fills the Gap While the License Clears

A hiring and licensing timeline is not a reason to pause new-business prospecting while it runs. Human + AI SDRs keep qualified meetings landing on an agency’s calendar during exactly that kind of gap, so the agency’s pipeline is not also waiting on the same clock a new producer’s license is.

Sources

The external data in this article draws on the sources below. Figures described in the text as estimates or industry triangulations are directional and are not attributed to a single dataset.

FAQ

Why is hiring harder in commercial insurance than in VA Horizon’s other B2B verticals?
Because insurance is the only one of the six verticals VA Horizon serves that requires a state-issued producer license before a new hire can legally solicit business. SaaS, MCA, merchant services, staffing, and marketing-agency sales roles all let a trained new hire start selling immediately.
How big is the licensing system a new insurance hire has to clear?
Large and active. The National Insurance Producer Registry processed approximately 185.9 million credentialing and reporting transactions in 2025 alone, a 29% year-over-year increase, and collected roughly $1.38 billion in state licensing and regulatory fees.
How bad is the insurance producer shortage?
The industry faces an estimated 400,000-worker deficit from retirements, with a workforce skewed sharply older, 1.37 million workers aged 55 or older against just 214,000 aged 20 to 24.
What does it cost if a licensed new hire does not work out?
75% to 150% of their salary, $15,000 to $50,000 in direct replacement cost, against a sales cycle that can take over two years to convert a first prospect into a client, meaning a bad hire is an expensive mistake discovered slowly.
What should an agency do about new-business prospecting while a new hire is getting licensed?
Keep it running rather than pausing it. A hiring and licensing timeline does not have to mean a frozen pipeline in the meantime.

While the license clears, the pipeline does not have to wait.

Book a 15-minute call and see how Human + AI SDRs keep qualified meetings landing on your calendar during a hiring and licensing gap, in insurance or any of the industries we serve.

Book a B2B Call

Pay per booked meeting · No retainer · Free no-show replacement