Angi Alternatives for Roofing Contractors
Angi and HomeAdvisor sell shared leads, typically resold to 3 to 8 contractors at once, for $15 to $120-plus per lead plus an annual membership around $300 to $400, and HomeAdvisor carries a 2023 FTC order over deceptive lead-marketing claims. Alternatives split into other shared marketplaces (Networx, CraftJack), exclusive-lead sellers (33 Mile Radius, Minyona), and appointment sellers that skip the lead entirely (The Lead Giants, VA Horizon at $300 setup plus $199 per booked appointment).
$300 setup + $199 per booked appointment.
Six real alternatives to Angi and HomeAdvisor.
Angi's core complaint pattern is well documented: the same homeowner request resold to several contractors at once, credits instead of cash refunds on bad leads, and early-termination fees that can reach 30% of the remaining contract. These six alternatives are ranked by how directly they solve that specific problem, from other shared marketplaces through exclusive-lead sellers to appointment sellers that remove the resale risk entirely.
#1
Networx
$14 to $120+ per lead; roofing specifically runs $20 to $60
- Offers a pricier "exclusive" tier ($15 to $120+) alongside its shared-lead pricing
- Same shared-marketplace mechanics as Angi at a comparable or slightly lower price floor
#2
CraftJack
$13 to $72 per lead
- The budget end of the shared-lead marketplace tier
- Its BBB profile lists the entity within the Angi brand family, indicating it now operates inside that consolidated marketplace
#3
33 Mile Radius
Custom quote only
- Exclusive pay-per-lead, focused on storm and disaster-mitigation work
- Claims its top partners close 90% of delivered leads (33 Mile Radius' own marketing claim, not independently verified)
#4
Minyona
$41 to $99 per exclusive lead, or $75 to $150 per booked appointment, plus a $2,000 setup fee
- Fully public pricing on both tiers, no monthly retainer
- Publishes its turnaround time and dispute process openly
#5
The Lead Giants
$175 to $200 per appointment, tiered by volume
- Skips the lead entirely and sells the booked estimate directly
- 24-hour replacement guarantee on bad appointments
Disclosed Position
VA Horizon
$300 one-time setup, then $199 per booked, double-confirmed appointment
- Exclusive to your business, never resold, unlike Angi's 3-to-8-way resale pattern
- No public FTC or comparable regulatory action
- Free no-show replacement, not a credit or a dispute process
Six alternatives, one table.
| Decision Point | VA Horizon | Field |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | A booked, double-confirmed estimate appointment. | A raw homeowner lead, resold to other contractors at the same time. |
| Exclusivity | Exclusive to your business, never resold. | Angi/HomeAdvisor leads are typically resold to 3 to 8 contractors per lead. (source) |
| Pricing | $300 one-time setup, then a flat $199 per booked appointment, published. | $15 to $120+ per lead plus an annual membership around $300 to $400. (source) |
| No-show / bad-lead protection | Free replacement, no dispute process. | Credits only, disputed case by case; early-termination fees can reach 30% of the remaining contract. (source) |
| Regulatory / trust record | No public FTC action or comparable order. | A 2023 FTC final order over deceptive lead-marketing and lead-quality claims. (source) |
The honest read.
Angi and HomeAdvisor are not going anywhere. They still move real volume, and for a contractor who needs raw contact numbers and can absorb a low hit rate, the price floor is genuinely hard to beat. But the well-documented complaint pattern, resold leads, credit-only refunds, early-termination fees up to 30%, and a 2023 FTC order over lead-marketing claims, is exactly what pushes contractors toward these six alternatives. Networx and CraftJack keep the shared-marketplace mechanics at a similar price. 33 Mile Radius and Minyona sell exclusivity at a premium. The Lead Giants and VA Horizon go furthest and sell the booked appointment itself, removing the resale problem entirely rather than pricing around it.
Angi alternatives, answered.
Are Angi and HomeAdvisor leads worth it for roofers?
What are the best Angi alternatives for roofing contractors?
Does Angi resell the same lead to my competitors?
What happened with the FTC and HomeAdvisor?
Is Networx or CraftJack better than Angi for roofers?
Stop competing for the same lead.
Book a 15-minute call. We confirm the $199 per-appointment rate and set your exclusive service area before your first booking.
Recommended next steps