Roofing Comparisons
Honest, sourced roundups and head-to-head comparisons for every roofing appointment-setting and lead-generation option.
The Best Roofing Appointment Setting Companies, Compared on Real Pricing
The roofing appointment setting field splits into companies that publish real pricing (The Lead Giants at $175 to $200 per appointment, Minyona at $75 to $150 per booked appointment plus a $2,000 setup fee, and VA Horizon at $300 setup plus $199 per appointment) and companies that quote only after a call (Storm911, Quality Contact Solutions, RoofNuts, and the newly launched Rizen Estimates). If a vendor will not show you a number before you talk to sales, treat that as data about how they price, not just a sales process.
Read more →Best Roofing Lead Generation Companies, Honestly Sorted
The top result for "best roofing lead generation company" is usually Hook Agency, an SEO and PPC firm that markets a roofer's own website rather than selling leads directly. Actual lead sellers in this space include Angi/HomeAdvisor and Networx (shared marketplace leads, $14 to $120+ per lead), 33 Mile Radius and Minyona (exclusive leads, $41 to $150 per lead or booked appointment), and appointment sellers like The Lead Giants and VA Horizon, which skip the lead entirely and sell a booked estimate for $199.
Read more →Best Exclusive Roofing Leads Companies, Compared
Exclusive roofing leads run $41 to $150 per lead or booked appointment depending on the vendor, versus $15 to $120 for a shared lead that gets resold to 3 to 8 contractors. 33 Mile Radius, Minyona, The Lead Giants, GenSales, and Predictive Sales AI all sell some form of exclusivity, though most quote custom pricing only after a call. VA Horizon takes exclusivity one step further and sells the appointment itself, not just an exclusive contact, for $300 setup plus $199 per booking.
Read more →Best Roofing Canvassing Companies (a Genuinely Thin Field)
There is almost no dedicated, done-for-you roofing canvassing company in the market: RoofNuts is the clearest example found, selling done-for-you D2D crews using HailTrace storm data. Most canvassing spend instead goes to software (SPOTIO, SalesRabbit, Knockbase) that equips an in-house team you still have to hire and pay, at a typical structure of $10 to $20 per hour plus a $20 to $30 per-appointment bonus plus 1% or more of the gross sale. VA Horizon is a different lane entirely: buy the booked estimate for $199 and skip the canvassing crew.
Read more →Best Pay-Per-Appointment Companies in Home Services
Pay-per-appointment is spreading across home services as a reaction to shared-lead fatigue. The Lead Giants and VA Horizon publish real per-appointment pricing ($175 to $200 and $199 respectively); Minyona publishes appointment pricing at $75 to $150 plus a $2,000 setup fee. Rizen Estimates and Storm911 both sell the model across multiple trades (Rizen also serves remodeling and HVAC; Storm911 also serves solar), but neither publishes pricing. Quality Contact Solutions bills by time, not per appointment, which is a different model worth knowing before you compare rates.
Read more →Angi Alternatives for Roofing Contractors
Angi and HomeAdvisor sell shared leads, typically resold to 3 to 8 contractors at once, for $15 to $120-plus per lead plus an annual membership around $300 to $400, and HomeAdvisor carries a 2023 FTC order over deceptive lead-marketing claims. Alternatives split into other shared marketplaces (Networx, CraftJack), exclusive-lead sellers (33 Mile Radius, Minyona), and appointment sellers that skip the lead entirely (The Lead Giants, VA Horizon at $300 setup plus $199 per booked appointment).
Read more →VA Horizon vs Angi Leads for Roofing Companies
Angi and HomeAdvisor sell shared leads: the same homeowner request resold to three to eight contractors, priced roughly $15 to $120 per lead plus an annual membership fee, with shared roofing leads closing at an estimated 8% to 20%. VA Horizon sells exclusive, double-confirmed booked appointments for a $300 one-time setup plus $199 per appointment, never resold, with free no-show replacement. They are different products: a raw contact you compete for versus a scheduled estimate already on your calendar.
Read more →VA Horizon vs HomeAdvisor Leads for Roofing Companies
HomeAdvisor sells shared roofing leads for $45 to $110 per lead sent, split among three to eight pros, with credits instead of cash refunds for bad leads and early-termination fees reported up to 30% of the remaining contract, plus cancellation fees exceeding $1,500 in contractor reports. VA Horizon sells an exclusive, double-confirmed booked appointment for a $300 one-time setup plus $199 per appointment, with free no-show replacement instead of a credit dispute and no annual contract required to start.
Read more →VA Horizon vs Networx for Roofing Companies
Networx sells both shared and "exclusive" roofing leads, priced $14 to $100+ on the shared tier and $15 to $120+ on the exclusive tier, with roofing and HVAC specifically running $20 to $60. VA Horizon sells a different product entirely: an already-booked, double-confirmed estimate appointment for a $300 one-time setup plus $199 per appointment, so you pay for a scheduled meeting, not a contact you still have to convert.
Read more →VA Horizon vs CraftJack for Roofing Companies
CraftJack sells budget-tier shared roofing leads for $13 to $72 each, and its BBB complaint file lists it as part of Angi's brand family, suggesting the brand now operates inside Angi's broader ecosystem rather than as a standalone company. VA Horizon sells an exclusive, double-confirmed booked appointment for a $300 one-time setup plus $199 per appointment, a different product built around a scheduled estimate rather than a cheap raw contact.
Read more →VA Horizon vs Door-to-Door Canvassing for Roofing Companies
Door-to-door canvassing crews are typically paid $10 to $20 an hour plus a $20 to $30 bonus per set appointment and 1% or more of the closed job's gross, based on pay structures roofing crews discuss on ContractorTalk. VA Horizon replaces the crew, the software, and the management with a flat $300 setup plus $199 per booked, double-confirmed appointment.
Read more →VA Horizon vs Building an In-House Canvassing Team
Building an in-house canvassing team means paying $10 to $20 an hour plus a $20 to $30 per-appointment bonus and 1% or more of gross on every closed job, then hiring, training, and managing turnover in a market that had 259,000 open construction positions as of April 2026, up 25% year over year. VA Horizon skips the payroll and the hiring funnel: $300 one-time setup, then $199 per booked, double-confirmed appointment.
Read more →VA Horizon vs The Storm-Chasing Model for Roofing Companies
The storm-chasing model means moving crews market to market to canvass within 24 hours of a hail or wind event, on a sales cycle that closes in 1 to 3 days, and 2025 gave storm-focused roofers plenty of material: NOAA recorded 5,432 hail events and State Farm alone paid more than $5.6 billion in hail claims. VA Horizon does not require you to chase the next storm: appointments are booked to your criteria, in season or not, for $300 setup plus $199 per appointment.
Read more →VA Horizon vs Buying Aged Roofing Leads
Aged roofing leads are contacts collected weeks or months ago, already worked and left unconverted by another buyer, then resold at a discount to the $15 to $120+ marketplaces like Angi and Networx charge for fresh leads. This research found no independent close-rate benchmark for aged roofing leads specifically, so VA Horizon's alternative is simpler to plan around: a fresh, double-confirmed booked appointment for $300 setup plus $199 per appointment, never resold and never aged.
Read more →Skip the research. Book the call.
See exactly how the roofing appointment model works for your business.
Recommended next steps